Home / Asset allocation / As equities get back to fundamentals, active management – at the right price – gains appeal

As equities get back to fundamentals, active management – at the right price – gains appeal

The recent re-embrace of active equity management by Australia's sovereign wealth fund may herald a shift in the active-versus-passive debate, industry leaders said, as market volatility prompts greater dispersion and allows active management - at the right price - to prove its worth.
Asset allocation

The eternal active-versus-passive debate got a shake-up earlier this month when the Future Fund revealed that it was once again backing active equity managers where it had previously held the view that they rarely generated outperformance – and that when they did, their ‘skill’ was usually indistinguishable from luck. But while a number of asset consultants and managers believe in active management, it comes with caveats.

“A strong focus on fees will lead you to passive, but we have a strong belief in active management,” Aongus O’Gorman, head of investments at WTW Australia, told The Inside Network’s Investment Symposium recently held on the Gold Coast. “Why [is the Future Fund] looking at getting back into [active management in] equities? Because what they’re observing in the market is that the volatility of the individual companies has been driven more by their fundamentals.”

“That’s caused greater dispersion between individual companies in indices, and that’s normally a good environment for active management. We believe in active management at the right price. If you’re paying too much, it’s going to be pretty hard to make money.”

  • When it comes to assessing the worth of a fund manager, Jake Jodlowski, principal of Atchison Consultants, said that “buying the market for zero is [the] starting point”.

    “In simplistic terms then, fund manager, you justify why we should invest with you and diversify away from the index at a certain cost,” Jodlowski said. “Our preference is to give a manager five years and see how they go through that cycle.

    “You’ve got to have patience. There isn’t an active manager in the country that isn’t trying to outperform whatever benchmark they’ve set themselves.”

    Brendan Paul, senior portfolio manager at Atrium, said the opportunity set for active management is “richer than it has been for years” but that as part of its risk-targeted approach Atrium spends a lot of time examining the holdings of its managers and the style or factor biases those managers can bring to the table. “Ultimately, they can play a big role in how diversifying their performance will be,” he said.

    “We focus on managers with quality bias, which refers to companies or corporates with very robust balance sheets, very strong structural growth drivers, very strong governance. Last year, [quality] still didn’t have a terrific year, but this year to date, with the prospect of a recession, that factor has been rewarded. It’s much better. And we’ve done a lot of research and we feel that quality is the right way to be positioned coming into these sorts of risks and uncertainty.”

    In the major asset classes, equities are optimistic, pricing a recovery from a recession “we haven’t had yet”; the bond market isn’t getting ahead of itself and is being more realistic, Paul said. The biggest opportunity now is to be “openminded” about portfolio construction.

    “It’s an exciting time,” he said. “Don’t fall back on a playbook that worked over the prior two decades of very plentiful liquidity and very low interest rates. You could argue that lifted all boats, providing strong structural tailwinds for a 60/40 or 70/30 portfolio. We’d prefer to be openminded about it and think about our diversification levers.”

    *A version of this story was originally published in our sister publication, Investor Strategy News.




    Print Article

    Related
    Several homes, shares and, of course, luxury: How the uber-wealthy invest

    Primary and secondary homes make up about a third of the total global wealth of the ultra-rich, new research shows. Commercial property and equities are also big components, with a small but increasingly valuable share going to “investments of passion”.

    Staff Writer | 8th Nov 2023 | More
    Thanks to rates reset, bond markets eye a 2024 ‘all about income’: AMP

    Higher bond yields are making fixed income fundamentally more attractive than it was during years of ultra-low interest rates. AMP’s Diana Mousina and Chris Baker recently discussed the opportunity set as investors look to add income and defensiveness in a new paradigm.

    Lisa Uhlman | 25th Oct 2023 | More
    Don’t expect low rates to return, Oaktree’s Marks says – instead, bet on debt

    Repeating his warning that markets are undergoing a “sea change” that will see a new set of winners and losers emerge in short order, the famed distressed-debt investor said it’s time to consider a profound shift from asset ownership to lending and credit.

    Lisa Uhlman | 18th Oct 2023 | More
    Popular